HomeMaltaPN: Caruana Must Publish Population Report Immediately

PN: Caruana Must Publish Population Report Immediately

Liene Avatar
619f38aed32d9b65c48dc5a9a16aeea010129926 1795262602 6d553efc 960x640 1

PN: Caruana must publish population report immediately, after the Partit Nazzjonalista has called on the Government to publish a population report written by Minister Clyde Caruana, saying he had been paid between €80,000 and €90,000 in public money for it, and saying the least the Government can do now is publish the report paid for by the people, always, if it has nothing to hide, in a demand that has become one of the most politically explosive rows in Malta in recent weeks, because it touches on the country’s number one issue, population growth, and on the question of whether the Government knew, as early as 2018, what that growth would do to Malta’s infrastructure, its public services, its quality of life, and chose to ignore it. According to the PN, Caruana told Parliament he could not publish the report without written permission from Prime Minister Robert Abela, and the party said this came less than 48 hours after Abela directed journalists to ask Caruana for the report, with Caruana responding to parliamentary questions from PN MPs Michael Piccinino, Darren Carabott and Beppe Fenech Adami, and with the PN accusing Caruana of trying to avoid publishing his own report, and of pressing the panic button over population growth now, while trying to escape publishing the report he wrote himself, and with the PN saying the same Prime Minister, whom Clyde Caruana indicated had warned him years ago about population growth, is now trying to pin it on his minister, and not only that, but in Parliament he appeared to pass the buck and asked him whether he had found the report. Finance Minister Clyde Caruana confirmed in Parliament on 17 November 2026 that he was paid between €80,000 and €90,000 for a report on population growth that the Government is refusing to publish, a report he wrote in 2018, when he was executive chairman of Jobsplus, although he has always maintained that he worked on it in his personal capacity, and several Nationalist Party MPs raised the issue of the report during question time in a parliamentary sitting on Tuesday afternoon, with the first question, asked by Michael Piccinino, concerning the payment Caruana received, and the minister saying he could not remember the exact amount at this moment, but confirming that he was paid between €80,000 and €90,000 for work that, by his account, took a full year to complete, in addition to his full-time role at Jobsplus, a statement that led to further questions about a report that in practice has become a commercial secret, because Caruana insists he cannot publish it because he was only its author, while Prime Minister Robert Abela says that those who want the report published should ask the author, and in effect, the two are shifting responsibility onto each other, although so far they have avoided doing so directly and have not named each other, and Caruana maintained his position on Tuesday, despite several questions from Piccinino, Beppe Fenech Adami and Darren Carabott, and refused to confirm directly that it was ultimately Abela who could have authorised the publication of the report. The report had been commissioned by the Office of the Prime Minister at a time when it was led by Abela’s predecessor, Joseph Muscat, however the report was not the personal property of Muscat, but of the Office of the Prime Minister, and therefore of the administration led by Abela, and Caruana reconfirmed that he has a copy of the report in his possession, but repeatedly insisted that it was the responsibility of whoever holds the report to publish it, without naming Abela, while Piccinino recalled that the day before, Abela himself had told party journalists that he was in favour of publishing a report which he claimed he did not have direct access to, and Abela has said the study is not held among Cabinet records, and has said there are no records of the population warning report in Cabinet minutes, and the Office of the Prime Minister has clarified that Finance Minister Clyde Caruana never actually handed over his report on the country’s population growth, and has denied that Caruana ever submitted a population report to Prime Minister Robert Abela, despite previous reports of population warnings being ignored by the government. The Clyde Caruana population report, commissioned during Joseph Muscat’s administration in 2018, remains unpublished despite renewed questions about its findings, ownership and the government’s willingness to release the document, and it is an approximately 300-page report, which examined the consequences of rapid population growth on Malta’s infrastructure and public services, and which, Caruana has said, warned about the consequences of Malta’s dependence on population growth to sustain economic development, and warned about the repercussions that the increase in population would have, and despite its potential relevance to government planning, the report was never published and its full recommendations remain unavailable for independent examination, and the continuing uncertainty surrounding the report raises important questions about transparency, document management and the use of publicly funded research in Malta, and about whether Caruana was told to burn it, as has been alleged, and about how shocking the contents of the report must be, such that they need to be hidden from the public, and about how shocking the fact is that the report was ignored. PN leader Alex Borg said the party would ask Clyde Caruana what his report contained, who received it and what action the Labour Government took, saying people have every right to know the truth about the report written by Clyde Caruana in which he warned about the repercussions that the increase in population would have, and in a social media message, Borg said a week had passed since Caruana announced that he had warned the Labour Government in 2018 about the consequences of that increase, and according to the PN, Caruana said he had knocked on all the Government’s doors, which the party argued also implicated Robert Abela, and Borg criticised Abela for not asking Caruana about the report, and said the PN would ask Caruana to explain clearly what it contained, to whom he had presented it and what the Labour Government had done about it, and the PN said the people paid for this report out of their own pockets, and today they continue to pay, at the expense of their quality of life, for the fact that this report has been hidden by the Government, and the least the Government can do now is publish the report paid for by the people, immediately, without further excuses, without further buck-passing, without further claims that permission is needed, or that the report cannot be found, or that it is not in Cabinet records, because if the people paid €80,000 to €90,000 for a 300-page warning about the future of their country, then the people have a right to read it.

Share on

Related posts